Your Breasts Don’t Lie: Soy, Flax and Other Estrogenic Foods and Herbs Trigger Precancerous Breasts

by Kaayla T. Daniel Healthy Living, The Naughty NutritionistComments: 88

estrogenic foods trigger abnormal breasts

by Kaayla T. Daniel, PhD, The Naughty Nutritionist®

Is thermography your “new breast friend”?

Wendy Sellens, a licensed acupuncturist and the founder of Pink Image Thermography in Solana Beach, CA, thinks so!

For every woman who wants to know the truth about the state of her breast health or whether those supposedly cancer-preventing supplements and estrogenic foods recommended by her doctor or holistic practitioner are actually working, her answer is simple: “Your breasts can’t lie.”

In Breast Cancer Boot Camp, coauthored with William B. Hobbins MD, Sellens provides striking, irrefutable visual evidence of adverse, precancerous effects on the breasts from birth control pills, hormone replacement therapies, and at least a dozen supposedly healthy estrogenic foods and herbs.

Most of these products come highly recommended by alternative doctors and other health care practitioners, yet promote angiogenesis in the breast, a known risk factor for breast cancer.

Angiogenesis refers to the formation of new blood vessels. It is crucial to form new blood vessels in the placenta during pregnancy and to replace blood vessels during recovery from an injury. Angiogenesis has a dark side, however, when it helps fuel cancer growth. Because thermograms —unlike mammograms or breast ultrasound — show vascularization, they are highly useful for breast health screening and monitoring.

Dr. Hobbins is a former surgeon who pioneered breast cancer detection through both mammography and thermography. Now 90, he continues to urge widespread use of thermography for initial screening and prevention because “the angiogenesis of a breast cancer is not only the earliest sign, but the greatest sign for detection and prognosis in treatment.” Back in the 1980s ,when soy was first widely marketed as a “health food,” Dr. Hobbins noted a link between soy consumption, increased vascularity and breast cancer development.

Sellens is a licensed acupuncturist and a protegé of Dr. Hobbins who studied with him for five years and spent seven years reviewing his thousands of cases. She founded Pink Image Thermography in Solana Beach, CA, is president and cofounder of the Women’s Academy of Breast Thermography, president of the non-profit Pink Bow Breast Thermography research and education, and is actively pushing for rigorous nationwide certification standards for thermography.

Thermography Can Tell You the Truth About Estrogenic Foods

Thermography is an imaging technique that can detect abnormalities based on patterns of bodily heat. Because cell proliferation and cancer rarely develops without a vascular process that increases the surface temperature, thermography can identify women at risk for breast cancer or who have breast cancer in a very early stage.

In color thermograms, the cooler areas appear dark blue, purple and black, while the warmer areas are yellow, orange, red and white. Gray scale thermographs show the vascularization itself. For highest diagnostic accuracy, Hobbins and Sellens recommend both types of thermograms be done and in high resolution.

Many alternative health professionals today recommend thermography as a safe screening alternative to mammography, which is not only painful and expensive but can increase breast cancer risk through radiation exposure and breast tissue compression. Thermograms are particularly helpful for the screening of women with young, dense breast tissue, and those with fibrocystic breast disease, breast implants or scars.

Unlike mammograms, thermograms are useful for detecting changes in the armpit area. Thermography is also safe for women who are pregnant or lactating.

Dr. Hobbins and Sellens furthermore recommend thermography because it can help women see the effects on their breasts of the many foods, herbs, supplements and other products commonly recommended to support breast health. They’ve consistently seen ill effects from the following:

  • Birth control pills
  • Hormone replacement therapies (including bioidentical hormone replacement therapies)
  • Soy, flax, red clover, alfalfa and other foods high in phytoestrogens
  • Black cohosh, red clover, xiang fu and other herbs high in phytoestrogens
  • Supplements such as DIM and calcium D-glucorate.

Particularly worrisome is their finding of unhealthy, vascularized breasts even in young women.

Exposure to environmental estrogens from pesticides, plastics, factory-farmed meats and tap water is part of the problem. So is birth control pill usage. “Breasts do not fully mature until age 25,” explains Sellens. “Breast development is adversely affected by unopposed estrogen . . . The younger the age, the higher the risk.” Birth control pills are widely dispensed today not only for contraceptive use but to regulate and mitigate the pain of menstrual periods.

Hormone Replacement Therapies

For older women, advocates of hormone replacement therapies not only promise an easy menopause but the fountain of youth. While the dangers of pharmaceutical hormone replacement therapy have been widely publicized, bioidentical hormone replacement therapy is widely promoted as safe and natural. Sadly, thermographic evidence does not bear this out. Bio-identical pills, pellets, patches, creams, all lead to increased vascularization.

“Weak” Estrogenic Foods?

Sellens and Dr. Hobbins particularly want to debunk the myth of “weak” estrogens as found in soy, black cohosh and other plant-based products. Although less potent than pharmaceutical estrogens, “weak” estrogens are not anti-estrogens and can still feed a cancer.

Back in the early 1980s Dr. Hobbins linked increased amounts of soy in the food supply to increased rates of breast cancer. While correlation doesn’t equal causation, thermograms confirmed his suspicions as he compared the breasts of women consuming soy to those who did not. In time, other scientific evidence emerged as well, much of which is discussed in my book The Whole Soy Story: The Dark Side of America’s Favorite Health Food.

By 2005 the Israeli Health Ministry had seen enough evidence to warn women to “exercise caution” regarding soy consumption, particularly if they’ve been diagnosed with, or have a family history of, breast cancer. The French Food Agency, German Institute of Risk Assessment and Cornell University’s Center for Breast Cancer and Environmental Risk Factors soon followed. Yet soy is still widely promoted as the ticket to breast cancer prevention, and manufacturers even give it out every October in pink containers — known as “pinkies” — at many Komen Races for the Cure.

Soybeans — both organic and GMO — are high in the phytoestrogens known as isoflavones. Clover and alfalfa sprouts are rich in the type known as coumestans, while flaxseeds and flax oil are rich in lignans. Although these phytoestrogenic foods are widely touted as cancer-preventing, thermograms show adverse effects on the breasts.

“Dr. Hobbins and I have gotten thousands of women off soy and flax,” says Sellen. “These estrogenic foods are not our friends, but foes.”

Similarly, black cohosh, red clover, evening primrose and xiang fu (cyperus rhizome) are estrogenic herbs.

“Thermograms show how strong these phytoestrogens really are,” says Sellens. “We see many women who start taking these supposedly healthy products go from ‘at risk’ thermograms to abnormal ones in three months or less. If these weakly estrogenic substances were ‘healthy’ for the breasts, we could expect women who regularly consume them to have non-vascular breasts, which would be evidence of a lack of stimulation and a protective effect.” Having analyzed thousands of thermograms, Sellens reports, “This is just not the case.”

Does all this seem hard to believe? Is it too hard to sort out the science? Could my doctor, hormone specialist or health care practitioner be so wrong? Sellens’ advice is simple: “Get a certified breast thermogram from an accredited clinic and take a look for yourself.”

Given that many naturopathic doctors and alternative health care practitioners regularly recommend these products, is a sobering reminder to us all that “natural” is not necessarily “safe.” Get a certified breast thermogram from an accredited clinic and see the truth staring back at you on the screen.

If women just stopped walking for a “cure” and stopped buying estrogen products, namely soy , flax and bioidentical estrogens, breast cancer numbers would plummet.

Stop believing flax, soy and bioidentical estrogen are healthy because they come from a plant. Stop believing they are weak estrogens because they are natural. Stop believing propaganda that estrogen keeps women young when it is in fact killing us.

Calcium D-Glucarate, DIM and Green Drink Powders

But what about Calcium D-Glucarate?  Can’t this bind and eliminate excess estrogen?

Calcium D-glucarate is a chemical. It is similar to a naturally occurring chemical called glucaric acid. Glucaric acid is found in our bodies as well as in fruits and vegetables such as oranges, apples, brussels sprouts, broccoli, and cabbage. Calcium D-glucarate is made by combining glucaric acid with calcium to make supplements that people use for medicine.

Calcium D-glucarate is used for preventing breast, prostate, and colon cancer; and for removing cancer-causing agents, toxins, and steroid hormones from the body.

Calcium D-glucarate might lower estrogen levels, and this is thought to be helpful in treating some people with hormone-dependent cancers. However, the truth is that there isn’t enough evidence to support the use of calcium D-glucarate for preventing cancer in humans.

Beware as well of DIM (Diindolylmethane) and other supplements said to bind excess estrogen or regulate estrogen metabolism. While doctors cite some science to support that, thermographic evidence suggests that in many cases they act like estrogens and worsen vascularity.

Given that DIM and similar supplements derive from compounds found in cruciferous vegetables such as cabbage, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower, and broccoli, it should not be surprising that some brands of green drink concentrate powders have proven problematic as well.

Angry?  Confused?  Here’s What to Do

Do it now.  Schedule a thermography appointment and go and see for yourself.  Look at the screen.  While your breasts are being imaged, the proof will be right before your eyes whether the therapies and supplements that you have been sold are actually working.

Question why if soy or edamame snacks are so good for breasts, flax is so healthy, and bioidentical hormones such a good way for women to stay young and sexy then why do they cause these unusual vascular and precancerous changes in breast tissue?

If this nutritional and health propaganda was true, then women who ingest these supposedly healthy estrogens should have nonvascular breasts. But nearly every woman who consumes these “good” estrogens shows an increased vascular pattern. If the theories were true, then thermography would support such claims with healthy breast tissue images.

However, the hard evidence points to the the exact opposite.

Settle the issue once and for all in your own mind and get a certified breast thermogram from an accredited clinic and take a look for yourself.   Your breasts don’t lie!

About the Author

dr kaayla danielKaayla T. Daniel, PhD, CCN is known as The Naughty Nutritionist® because of her ability to outrageously and humorously debunk nutritional myths.

She is author of The Whole Soy Story: The Dark Side of America’s Favorite Health Food.

Kaayla’s latest book —coauthored with Sally Fallon Morell— is Nourishing Broth: An Old-Fashioned Remedy for the Modern World. Join the broth-making community and receive “souper” free gifts at


More Information

170 Scientific Studies Confirm the Dangers of Soy

When Breast Cancer Isn’t Bad News

Komen (Not) for the Cure: The Complete and Utter Pinkwashing of America

Thermography: A Perfect Alternative to Cancer Causing Mammograms?

Why Even Organic Soy Formula is so Dangerous for Babies

How the Birth Control Pill Can Harm Your Future Child’s Health

Is Your Egg Allergy Really a Soy Allergy in Disguise?

Is Soy Lecithin Really So Unhealthy?

Comments (88)

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *