The first year we purchased a local turkey, we were told it would need to be brined.
Brining? What is that, we wondered?
While we are not pirate folk, we figured we could handle putting together a salty bath for our bird. Brining at home is definitely preferable to store bought poultry (even organic), which is usually injected with an industrial salt water solution. In other words, “brine” is just a fancy word for salt water, meaning that when you purchase poultry at the store, you are paying for a bunch of processed salt water at the same time (and at the same price!) as the meat. Conveniently, food producers don’t call this process brining, but instead refer to it as “plumping,” perhaps because they are “plumping their pockets” with additional profits from selling salt water for the same price per pound as the meat itself! Estimates run as high as two billion dollars (yes billion!) per year being pilfered from consumers through this practice.
How much salt water are you paying for? On a large turkey, it can be many pounds worth of water and up to 30% of the total price you pay at checkout. This plumping thing isn’t just standard practice for chicken or turkey either. Some grocery stores and meat processors do it to pork as well. The water weight isn’t the only problem, as the plumped meat you end up eating means you are getting multiple times the USDA RDA (Recommended Daily Allowance)of industrialized salt – the type of sodium you want to avoid.
While Real Foodies know the benefits of real salt, you can bet your bottom dollar that these industrialized injections are the farthest thing from it, with tests showing over 400 to 800 mg per serving of processed sodium.
So, for both your personal health and pocketbook, poultry plumped with injected brinewater is problematic to purchase.
Wet Brining vs Dry Brining
Our first pastured turkey weighed in at almost 20 pounds. It required a 5 gallon stockpot to submerge the beast. Some people use food grade bins or even coolers since the turkey plus water brine take up so much space. The pot plus brine reached maximum poundage for our refrigerator, and as I carefully placed it on a shelf, I saw and heard the glass protest under the burden. The turkey turned out well and was well praised by guests. But I always remembered and have now read horror stories about the weight of a wet brined turkey shattering glass in many a fridge. What a dangerous mess that would be!
For a few years we continued wet brining similarly until one Fall day a friend mentioned the traditional technique of dry brining. No massive amounts of water to slosh and spill (or dispose of!). Shorter cooking time. Superior flavor penetration. He ticked off a host of benefits. I was immediately intrigued and set about learning more and preparing to change our holiday practice.
The Science of Dry Brining
Dry brining is some sort of culinary alchemy, taking flavors deep into the meat in a most mysterious manner. By coating the outside of a cut with a mixture of salt, herbs, and spices, a set of beneficial reactions ensues.
First, the salt pulls moisture out of the meat! Yes, out.
This may seem like a bad thing at first, butt a certain point, the meat then begins to pull this moisture back in, along with the salt and spice mixture. This pull-push of moisture allows the salt and spices to move deeply into the meat. It also changes the meat’s structure, tightly binding the moisture in its folds and improving the texture.
Benefits of Dry Brined Meat
There are four main benefits of dry brining meat versus the more typical practice of wet brining. They include:
– Much shorter cooking time with reductions by as much as 1/3
– Increased resistance to accidental overcooking (meat holds onto its moisture better)
– Superior flavor penetration, since the salt carries herbs and spices deep into the meat
– Succulent meat texture, no rubbery or watery portions which can sometimes occur with wet brining.
Complete Dry Brining Guide
Here’s how long you’ll need to dry brine various cuts of meat prior to cooking.
Smaller cuts: 1/2-2 1/2 pounds (steaks, roasts, breasts) – 12-24 hours
Medium cuts – three to eight pounds (whole chickens, large roasts) – 24-36 hours
Large cuts – Greater than eight pounds- 48-72 hours
Also consider that cut shape matters a lot when dry brining. A longer, wider, but thinner cut will take less time than a rounder, bulkier, more compact cut. So a chuck roast needs less time than an equally sized rump roast. A spatchcocked chicken or turkey will take less time than a whole chicken or turkey. Adjust your brining time accordingly.
Another important note: you will do little harm going longer with your dry brine. The rules above are minimums to help ensure success. If a cut sits an extra day or so, it has never in our experience negatively impacted the meat or meal in any way. As long as you used sufficient salt, herbs, and spices, and the cut was not already older, it should also keep the meat safer than if it was sitting solo.
Dry Brining Steps
Start with a cut of meat that has not been “plumped,” pre-seasoned, pre-salted or otherwise processed in any way. This includes Kosher meat.
- First, make sure the meat is dry. Use a towel or paper towels to remove excess moisture from the meat. In our experience, this is easy with most cuts, except for whole pastured chickens and sometimes turkeys from small, local farms. These tend to have a fair amount of excess water from the water bath chilling process these farmers usually use, and may require sitting out for a ten minutes or more on a towel to drain. For chickens and turkeys, this is also the time to remove any organs and the neck if they were tucked into the cavity.
- Next, for each pound of meat, mix 1/4 – 1/2 teaspoon salt and 1/8 – 1/4 teaspoon of herbs/spices for each pound (.45 kilo) of meat. Rub the meat thoroughly all over. Meatier spots need more of the dry brine, so especially focus on poultry breasts.
A few suggestions …
If you have never dry brined before, I suggest before doing it for some special occasion or on some super large cut of meat (like a Thanksgiving turkey or a standing rib roast), to do it on a smaller, similar cut, like a whole chicken or some steaks before moving on up. Since dry brining can use a range on the amount of salt and spices, you can also get a feel for which end of the range you prefer per pound.
Since dry brining changes cooking times, the first few times make sure to keep an eye on your meat. An added bonus to the shorter cooking span means meats take up less time in the oven on busier cooking days, like holidays.
How to Dry Brine: Basic Recipe
Dry Brining Recipe
Basic dry brining recipe for any type of meat or poultry.
Pat meat dry with paper towel.
Thoroughly rub down/coat with brining mixture.
Place into a large bag (sources) and seal.
Every 12 hours rub meat down through the bag.
Dry brine chicken and roasts for 24-36 hours, steaks and smaller cuts for 24 hours, and turkey for 48-72 hours.
Adjust sea salt and herb mix used depending on how much meat you will be using: ¼-½ tsp of coarse sea salt and ⅛-¼ tsp of herbs/spices for each pound (.45 kilo) of meat
Dried sage, thyme, rosemary, and marjoram are great herbs to use (organic if possible as non-organic spices are frequently irradiated).
Herbs de Provence is a simple mix to use for dry brining that is delicious. We also love the Thai organic seasoning blend from Frontier, though it is one among many organic seasoning blends you can try and use instead of making your own.
Since the amount of salt and herbs is somewhat up to preference, I encourage people to try out dry brining on some chickens a few weeks before Thanksgiving or Christmas to see what they like best.
Three Reasons to Dry Brine
Still not convinced to try it and wanting to stick with tried and true wet brine? Here’s a summary of the three big reasons to give it a chance this year.
- Takes turkey prep out of the craziness of the big day due to significantly shorter cooking time.
- Removes the danger and potential mess of having a massive, incredibly heavy pot of sloshing water in your fridge. Might even save your back from going out!
- Results in a more evenly and thoroughly flavored bird, with improved moisture and texture.
Dry Brining: Three Things to Watch Out For
While a much easier process overall, there are a few things to watch out for when you dry brine. Here’s a quick summary of the caveats mentioned earlier.
- Dry brining reduces cooking time so watch the meat carefully.
- Don’t get a kosher (pre-salted) or pre-seasoned and salted turkey. You want a truly au-natural bird.
- Meatier spots need more dry brine, breasts especially.
Have you ever dry brined or wet brined pastured meats? If so, please let us know your experiences and what differences you noted between the two methods. Did you prefer one over the other?
The Healthy Home Economist holds a Master’s degree from the University of Pennsylvania. Mother to 3 healthy children, blogger, and best-selling author, she writes about the practical application of Traditional Diet and evidence-based wellness within the modern household. Her work has been featured by USA Today, The New York Times, National Review, ABC, NBC, and many others.