The war against genetically modified organisms expands to include animals as the private firm Oxitec readies a planned release of GE mosquitoes in the Florida Keys as early as January 2012.
The mutant mosquitoes are genetically modified to contain a gene that will kill them unless they come in contact with the antibiotic tetracycline.
This lethal gene is passed on to any mutant offspring when the GE mosquitoes mate with wild mosquitoes. Any offspring born with this gene will then die before adulthood. The theory is that over time, the mosquito population will decline due to the lethal gene becoming more widespread.
Residents of the Florida Keys have not been asked to approve this release despite the fact that they would be potential bite victims given that .5% of the to be released mutants are female (the female mosquito is the one that bites).
Two previous releases of the GE mosquitoes (aedes aegypti) occurred in the Cayman Islands and Malaysia. The Cayman release, performed without residents’ permission, resulted in an 80% drop in the mosquito population compared with neighboring areas that did not have a release. The success of this release was discussed in a scientific paper in the journal Nature Biotechnology.
Many unanswered questions about the impending release in Florida remain including what will happen with a reduction in the mosquito population in the release area? Will the void be filled by another insect species inadvertently creating new, unforeseen and perhaps irreversible problems?
What will happen to the balance of the local ecosystem? Florida bats, for example, depend on mosquitoes for food. Would such a release have unintended consequences and potentially threaten this fragile mammalian species already in alarming decline?
Who is responsible financially or otherwise if complications with the release develop?
Hopefully, residents of the Florida Keys will demand an open discussion of this impending release in a public forum and that no such experiments be allowed to proceed without their permission.
As with the haphazard and unpredictable spread of GM crops around the globe (feral GM canola growing in ditches in Japan, for example), there is no doubt that the release of GE animals particularly one like the mosquito that has the ability to hitch a ride and move unrestrained into any uncontained area will have far reaching consequences that the scientific mind can only feebly begin to comprehend.
Sarah, The Healthy Home Economist
Source: Genetically Modified Mosquitoes to be Released in US for the First Time
An acquaintance recently said they spray the fields in Cape Coral for mosquitoes etc. is this common & should we be concerned?
Oh, this is an awesome idea. I don’t see ANYTHING that could possibly go wrong with this brilliant plan.
As a biologist, I understand the lifecycle of mosquitos, their place in the food web, and the domino effect that occurs when you remove one species or lower its numbers. The number of birds and bats that feed on mosquitos would also decline in number, move to an area with more mosquitos or have to adapt and develop a different niche. My “feeble scientific mind” also questions the effect upon the birds and bats that eat the GM mosquitos. I do find it odd that Sarah decided to refer to scientists as “feeble” minded when it was scientists that came up with all the information she uses in her blog about mosquitos. If Sarah really thinks that scientists are not thinking about the ramifications that this type of mosquito release would cause then she is the one with the feeble mind. I am sure choosing the Florida Keys as the release site was done after a long scientific investigation into the best site for this study. I highly doubt that they pulled the site out of a hat. If you are going to be outraged about releasing GM mosquitos in the Florida Keys, why are you not outraged about the other GM foods and organisms you come into contact with on a daily basis? Do you realize that humans have been manipulating organisms for almost as long as humans have inhabited the Earth? Humans have been selectively breeding organisms to obtain the desired traits for thousands of years, in the end they can achieve similar results, it just takes hundreds of generations to get there.